The BBC is preparing to release the long-awaited findings of an internal investigation into the controversial documentary Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone, which was pulled from iPlayer earlier this year after serious editorial concerns were raised.
The documentary, produced by independent company Hoyo Films, came under fire after it was revealed that the English-language narrator, Abdullah Al-Yazouri, is the son of a Hamas minister—information that was not disclosed to audiences. The film, which initially received critical acclaim, portrayed life in Gaza through the eyes of three young people and aired in February 2025.
Peter Johnston, the BBC’s director of editorial complaints and reviews, has led the investigation. His upcoming report is expected to be a tough reckoning for the broadcaster, determining whether BBC editorial standards were breached and potentially laying the groundwork for disciplinary actions.
Sources say the review process, which included a legal step allowing individuals involved to respond to criticisms, has been fraught with tension. Some staff members involved in the production have reportedly sought legal representation, and there is concern among insiders that they may be publicly named in the final report.
The BBC initially pointed to the production company, Hoyo Films, for failing to disclose the narrator’s background. However, the corporation later acknowledged it should have done more to verify key details, including whether any production payments may have indirectly benefited Hamas.
The situation has attracted political and public pressure. Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy has called for accountability, questioning why no one has been dismissed.
Meanwhile, groups on both sides of the political spectrum have voiced strong opinions—Jewish industry figures raised concerns about editorial failures, while others, including celebrities Gary Lineker and Riz Ahmed, criticized the film’s removal as censorship.
The BBC’s leadership has already admitted the damage to its reputation. Chair Samir Shah called the incident “a dagger to the heart” of the broadcaster’s credibility and expressed concerns that the failure was not just procedural, but a result of individuals not fulfilling their responsibilities.
The BBC’s report is expected to be released next week, alongside its annual report and an unrelated investigation involving former MasterChef host Gregg Wallace.
