Netflix’s new thriller “His & Hers” is facing criticism from viewers over what many are calling a major plot hole. The six-part series, released last week, has drawn strong reactions online despite solid early reviews.
The show stars Tessa Thompson and Jon Bernthal as estranged spouses pulled back together during a murder investigation in a small Georgia town. The story has kept many viewers hooked, but some say one key detail does not add up.
At the center of the debate is Thompson’s character, Anna Andrews, and her past trauma involving former classmates. As the story unfolds, it becomes clear that one of the people involved is Jack Harper’s sister, Zoe.
Viewers are confused about why Anna would later marry Jack, knowing his sister played a role in what happened to her years earlier. Many say the show never clearly explains this decision.
Fans also question why Anna kept this information from Jack during their marriage. For some viewers, this makes the relationship hard to believe and weakens the overall story.
Social media platforms like Reddit and X are filled with posts calling the issue “mind-boggling.” Several viewers say it is one of the biggest inconsistencies in the series.
Some fans have shared their own theories to explain it. A popular idea is that Anna stayed close to the family as part of a long-term plan to confront her past, or that complicated emotions led her into the relationship.
Netflix has not responded to the criticism so far. Despite the backlash, “His & Hers” remains one of the platform’s most talked-about new releases, proving that viewer debate is only adding to its buzz.
