Disney is facing a new copyright lawsuit just weeks before Academy Award nominations, with animator Buck Woodall accusing the studio of stealing ideas from his screenplay, Bucky, for Moana and its sequel, Moana 2.
The Allegations
Woodall claims both Moana and Moana 2 share striking similarities with his screenplay, which revolves around a Polynesian village, teenagers embarking on dangerous voyages, and spiritual ancestors manifested as animals.
He alleges Disney had access to his work when he shared Bucky materials with a former Disney affiliate in 2003.
Key overlaps cited include:
- A protagonist’s journey beginning with a turtle.
- A symbolic necklace central to the plot.
- A demigod adorned with a hook and tattoos.
- A giant creature hidden within a mountain.
- A whirlpool-like oceanic portal featured in both Bucky and Moana 2.
Legal Context
This lawsuit follows a previous case in which Woodall sued Disney over Moana. That case was dismissed due to statute of limitations, but the court acknowledged potential similarities between the works.
With the release of Moana 2, Woodall has revived his claims, seeking $10 billion in damages—2.5% of Moana‘s gross revenue—and a ban on further copyright infringement.
Disney’s Defense
Disney denies the allegations, stating Moana and its sequel were independently developed.
Director Ron Clements and Disney have submitted documents, including story ideas and research, to prove the films’ originality.
Impact on Moana 2
Despite the lawsuit, Moana 2 has been a massive success, grossing $224.2 million during its debut and smashing box office records. It remains a strong contender for an Academy Award nomination for Best Animated Feature.
The case highlights ongoing tensions in Hollywood over intellectual property and the creative process, with Woodall determined to seek recognition for his work.