The Toronto Blue Jays have lost a unique young prospect, as 24‑year‑old Nate LaRue has retired from professional baseball following an injury setback and an unsuccessful position change.
LaRue’s retirement was first reflected on his official player profile, signaling an abrupt end to his career in the Blue Jays’ system. The move comes as Toronto continues reshaping its major‑league roster following its American League pennant‑winning season.
Originally drafted as a catcher in the 2019 MLB Draft, LaRue spent several seasons behind the plate. He even appeared in a Double‑A game in 2023, but his progress stalled after offensive struggles in the minors.
Ahead of the 2025 season, LaRue attempted a full‑time transition to pitcher, a rare move for a minor‑league player who had already reached the upper levels as a position player. The switch followed years of injuries and declining production as a hitter.
LaRue’s first season on the mound proved difficult. He posted a 5.30 ERA across 27 games in High‑A and Single‑A, struggling to establish himself as a viable pitching prospect.
His conversion to pitching followed an ankle injury in spring training of 2024 that required surgery. Despite briefly returning to catching late that season due to team injuries, organizational discussions about a permanent move to pitching resumed.
After failing to gain traction in his new role, LaRue appears to have decided to walk away from baseball entirely, ending hopes that he could eventually contribute at the major‑league level.
While the Blue Jays have strengthened their pitching staff at the top of the roster, LaRue’s retirement closes the book on a rare and unconventional development path that once made him a notable prospect within the organization.